实战练英文 | 想进哈佛或谷歌，亚裔及白人要被扣多少分才算对
字幕摘录
| 时间 | 英文 | 中文 |
|---|---|---|
| 0:00 | Therefore a white male should not be treated differently than a black male | 因此,不应对白人男性区别对待。 |
| 0:04 | But when you come from a difference doesn't matter, but what but the | 但当你从一个差异 不重要,但除了 |
| 0:09 | Equal treatment or not. | 平等相待否. |
| 0:10 | It's not whether or not you were said meant mean things and you grew up or whether your dad was a gang | 你长大了 你爸爸是不是黑帮 |
| 0:13 | Banger doesn't matter. | 班杰无关紧要 |
| 0:14 | Well, I'm not saying that that is that's not the outside factors. | 我不是说这不是外在因素 |
| 0:18 | I'm talking about doesn't matter | 我说的不重要 |
| 0:20 | Can I explain where I'm going to finish? | 我能解释一下我在哪里完成吗? |
| 0:22 | I'll let you talk. | 我让你说 |
| 0:23 | Okay equal treatment is | 好吧,平等待遇是 |
展开字幕全文（611 条）
| 序号 | 英文 | 中文 |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Therefore a white male should not be treated differently than a black male | 因此,不应对白人男性区别对待。 |
| 2 | But when you come from a difference doesn't matter, but what but the | 但当你从一个差异 不重要,但除了 |
| 3 | Equal treatment or not. | 平等相待否. |
| 4 | It's not whether or not you were said meant mean things and you grew up or whether your dad was a gang | 你长大了 你爸爸是不是黑帮 |
| 5 | Banger doesn't matter. | 班杰无关紧要 |
| 6 | Well, I'm not saying that that is that's not the outside factors. | 我不是说这不是外在因素 |
| 7 | I'm talking about doesn't matter | 我说的不重要 |
| 8 | Can I explain where I'm going to finish? | 我能解释一下我在哪里完成吗? |
| 9 | I'll let you talk. | 我让你说 |
| 10 | Okay equal treatment is | 好吧,平等待遇是 |
| 11 | Regardless of any sort of sob story you could put on before it equal treatment | 不管什么悲哀的故事,你可以在它面前 平等的待遇 |
| 12 | Yeah, so basically at Harvard Asian and white students | 是啊,所以基本上 在哈佛亚洲和白人学生 |
| 13 | They basically got two to four hundred points knocked off of their score versus black and Hispanic students | 他们基本上得到了两到四百分 打破他们的分数 黑人和西班牙裔学生 |
| 14 | So it was disenfranchising white and Asian students. | 因此,它剥夺了白人和亚洲学生的权利。 |
| 15 | So if you support DEI, let's say you're in truck. | 所以,如果你支持DEI, 让我们假设你在卡车。 |
| 16 | You're in charge | 你负责 |
| 17 | Do you think that we should have all test scores be weighed the same? | 你觉得我们所有的测试成绩 都一样吗? |
| 18 | Or do you think that certain ethnic groups should get certain points because of their race? | 或者你认为某些族群应该因为种族而获得一定的分数? |
| 19 | I | 一、导 言 |
| 20 | Believe that we should acknowledge the fact that certain students have a different starting point | 相信我们应该承认 某些学生有一个不同的起点 |
| 21 | And I would love to give everybody the opportunity to go | 我很乐意给大家去的机会 |
| 22 | How many points should a black student get over a white student in admissions? | 黑人学生在招生中要过白人学生多少分?. |
| 23 | I think that SAT scores and points shouldn't be the only thing | 我认为SAT的分数和分数 不应该是唯一的事情 |
| 24 | You have to answer the question because the status quo it's not that black and white it is so it is | 你必须回答这个问题 因为现状不是黑白一样 |
| 25 | Secondly you you have not answered this fundamental question though, which is can you tell me when a | 第二,你还没有回答这个根本的问题, 你可以告诉我当一个 |
| 26 | Organization gets forcibly more diverse. | 组织被迫变得更加多样化。 |
| 27 | It gets better | 越来越好 |
| 28 | Google again, I just proved to you Google. | 谷歌再次,我刚刚向你证明了谷歌。 |
| 29 | Okay. | 摆 |
| 30 | I just gave you Google again. | 我又给你谷歌了 |
| 31 | They use the I not only are they one of the best companies | 他们利用我 不仅是他们最好的公司之一 |
| 32 | I mean again, it's just they're fine | 再说一遍,他们没事 |
| 33 | I'm not gonna like totally kind of crap on Google but like more importantly and more more broadly | 我不会完全喜欢谷歌的废话 但喜欢更重要的,更广泛的 |
| 34 | I do think you have to answer the question. | 我认为你必须回答这个问题。 |
| 35 | So I can't why does skin color matter at all in hiring answer that question? | 所以,我无法解释为什么 皮肤颜色在雇用中很重要 回答这个问题? |
| 36 | Why does skin color matter? | 为什么皮肤颜色很重要? |
| 37 | So | 这么说 |
| 38 | My name is Layla and I've recently watched three videos of yours best top ten Charlie Kirk debate moments of 2024 students | 我叫莱拉 最近我看了三部你最优秀的电影 Charlie Kirk在2024届学生辩论时 |
| 39 | Students enraged that I say college of the scam and ten unforgettable Charlie Kirk debates that shook 2024 and I picked | 学生们愤怒地说,我说大学 骗局和十次令人难忘的查理・柯克辩论 震撼了2024,我挑了 |
| 40 | three different topics that I think are important to me which comes down to immigration affirmative action the NDI and | 我认为有三个不同议题对我很重要, 归根结底是移民平权行动 NDI 和 |
| 41 | College is a scam, but the one I want to talk to you about the most is affirmative action in DEI and | 大学是个骗局 但我最想跟你说的是 DEI的平权行动 |
| 42 | In these videos you have said quote for quote | 在这些视频中,你引用了 |
| 43 | White males have high test scores white males have or white male shouldn't have to be penalized | 白人雄性测试分数很高 白人雄性或者白人雄性不该受到惩罚 |
| 44 | You did acknowledge and say that people have come from lower social and on it | 你承认并说人们来自社会底层 |
| 45 | Socio-economic backgrounds that do not prioritize education much | 不太重视教育的社会经济背景 |
| 46 | But instead of making a suggestion on how to help those communities and | 但是,与其建议如何帮助这些社区和 |
| 47 | Continue to like build those communities up | 继续喜欢建设这些社区 |
| 48 | You continue to say that our institutions are becoming less excellent and I'm confused | 你继续说 我们的机构越来越不优秀 我很困惑 |
| 49 | That's what your definition of excellence is is that because white males aren't necessarily in your opinion getting accepted as in a higher rate | 这就是你对优秀的定义 是因为白人雄性不一定在你看来 被接受为高比率 |
| 50 | Even though they technically are because 41% of college admitted students are of the white it should be higher than that | 虽然从技术上讲 41%的大学生是白人 但应该比白人高 |
| 51 | Based on what where are you getting the statistic I just want to say it's a good question | 根据你从哪里得到的数据 我只想说 这是一个很好的问题 |
| 52 | The Supreme Court did a whole case on this and it ruled against affirmative action and we saw the books of Harvard | 最高法院做了一个完整的案件 并裁定 平权行动,我们看到了哈佛的书 |
| 53 | So I don't want to cut you off man know the so like for future reference | 所以,我不想切断你 男人知道这样的未来参考 |
| 54 | I can understand where you're coming from and get more context could I know the Supreme Court case? | 我能理解你从哪里来 得到更多的背景 我能知道最高法院的案子吗? |
| 55 | Yeah, so it's the name | 是啊,所以这是名字 |
| 56 | Boy two and a half years ago. | 男孩两年半前。 |
| 57 | I think it was something out of California | 我觉得是加州的东西 |
| 58 | Someone look it up you use grok or check if somebody could please look that up | 找找看,你用grok或检查是否有人可以查一下 |
| 59 | Yeah, so so we saw that we saw the data out of Harvard Harvard was the test case and effectively | 所以我们看到哈佛大学的数据 是测试案例 |
| 60 | Approximating but a white male had to get | 貌似是,但一个白人男性必须得到 |
| 61 | About a 30% higher test score to even be considered than an equivalent black and one was this over 30 years | 大约30%的测试分数 甚至比相等的黑人高, 其中之一是30年 |
| 62 | Yeah, I think so. | 是的,我想是这样。 |
| 63 | Yeah, I think so | 是的,我想是这样 |
| 64 | So it was so basically for a black student they could do 30% worse on their standardized scores than an equivalent white | 所以对于一个黑人学生来说 他们的标准分数比白人要差30% |
| 65 | Don't think that has any outside factors to do with it | 别以为这有什么外在因素 |
| 66 | Well, that's not the point. | 这不是重点 |
| 67 | The point is whether or not but how is that not the point? | 关键是,是否但为什么这不是重点? |
| 68 | Because I don't believe we should accommodate based on outside factors you do | 因为我不认为我们应该适应 根据外界因素你做的 |
| 69 | Well, I do because I believe in progression and I feel like you have stated in multiple of your videos | 我这样做是因为我相信进步 我感觉你已经在你的多段视频里说过了 |
| 70 | Which I do have a quote fair enough. | 我确实有很公平的引用 |
| 71 | I'm just making sure we understand we disagree | 我只是要确保我们理解 我们不同意 |
| 72 | I know I don't think we should change the rules of the game to accommodate the rules of the game | и笵иぃ莱赣э跑笴栏規矩 |
| 73 | Well, the rules of the game are that you should be treated fairly and equally right sure that's an American principle | 好吧,游戏规则是,你应该得到公平 和平等的正确待遇,肯定这是美国的原则 |
| 74 | And I agree with that completely so therefore a white male should not be treated differently than a black male | 我完全同意,所以白人男性 不应该被区别对待 黑人男性 |
| 75 | But when you come from a difference doesn't matter but what but the | 但当你从一个差异 并不重要,但什么是 |
| 76 | Equal treatment or not. | 平等相待否. |
| 77 | It's not whether or not you were said meant mean things and you grew up or whether your dad was a gang | 你长大了 你爸爸是不是黑帮 |
| 78 | Banger doesn't matter. | 班杰无关紧要 |
| 79 | Well, I'm not saying that that is that's not the outside factors. | 我不是说这不是外在因素 |
| 80 | I'm talking about doesn't matter | 我说的不重要 |
| 81 | Equal treatment is regardless of any sort of sob story you could put on before it equal treatment test score test score | 同等待遇无论在同等待遇考试分数前 写什么悲哀故事 |
| 82 | And I completely agree with that, but I also come from a predominantly white town | 我完全同意 但我也来自一个以白人为主的小镇 |
| 83 | So I understand what you're what you're trying to say in my district. | 所以我理解你在我区里想说什么 |
| 84 | We have | 我们有 |
| 85 | So much funding and I live in the floor keys | 这么多资金,我住在地板钥匙里 |
| 86 | So there's a lot of funding that comes to my school and you can drive | 所以,有很多资金 来到我的学校,你可以开车 |
| 87 | 30 miles north and you get end up in homestead where they have a | 北边30英里,你最后会回到家 |
| 88 | Fraction of the funding that we have and they don't have as much of the same | 我们拥有的资金少而他们没有那么多 |
| 89 | Test like testing instructors and people to help them and have as much of the same outside resources | 测试比如测试指导员和人员帮助他们 并且拥有同样多的外部资源 |
| 90 | And then you can keep going another 30 miles and you end up in Miami where all the private schools are and they get | 然后你可以继续走30英里 到迈阿密所有私立学校都在那里 |
| 91 | even more funding than where I come from and they and not that I | 比我从哪里来的资金还要多 而不是我 |
| 92 | obviously I ended up where I am today because I | 很明显,我最终走到今天的地步 因为我 |
| 93 | Continue to push through and I have and I didn't let any outside factors affect me | 继续推进,我有,我没有让任何外界因素影响我 |
| 94 | I | 一、导 言 |
| 95 | Kept going and some people don't have that same ability and I also it doesn't again | 坚持下去,有些人没有 同样的能力,我也不再 |
| 96 | No, first of all in Florida every public school gets the same amount of money. | 不,首先在佛罗里达 每个公立学校都得到同样的钱 |
| 97 | Okay, that's it. | 好了 就这样 |
| 98 | There's it | 就是这样 |
| 99 | There's an equal funding | 资金是平等的 |
| 100 | Yeah, but across the board, but you also get donations from the people in your fair enough | 是的,但是你得到的捐赠 在你的公平。 |
| 101 | But Florida and I know for a fact that my community gets many | 但佛罗里达和我知道一个事实 我的社区得到很多 |
| 102 | Florida has the most you could use equitable funding structure of any school and as universal school choice basically, so that's number one number two | 佛罗里达州最能利用任何学校的公平资助结构 基本上作为学校的普及选择 所以这是头号 |
| 103 | Explain to me why when we're admitting people for a job | 给我解释一下为什么我们接纳别人来工作 |
| 104 | Should it just be what's on that piece of paper or should should race play into the factor? | 应该是那张纸上的什么 还是应该把比赛玩进因素里? |
| 105 | So I know that your argument is me mediocrity | 所以我知道你的争论是平庸的 |
| 106 | Many I forgot I don't really awkward II. | 很多我都忘了 我并不觉得尴尬 |
| 107 | Okay. | 摆 |
| 108 | Yeah, and I know that and I also believe in quotas as well | 是的,我知道,我也相信配额 |
| 109 | But I don't think that it should be one-in-one | 但我不认为是一对一 |
| 110 | But they should go hand-in-hand | 但他们应该齐头并进 |
| 111 | Because at the end of the day if I have just as good as a resume as somebody next to me | 因为到最后 如果我和身边的人一样有履历 |
| 112 | I want to I want to understand where you're getting that jobs are just taking people because they're a woman because they are black | 我想了解你从哪里得到的 工作就是因为别人是女人 因为他们是黑人 |
| 113 | I just want to see and I understand what you're trying to say because of of course with affirmative action in DEI | 我只是想看看 我知道你想说什么 因为当然肯定行动 在DEI |
| 114 | That does give them an upper hand | 让他们占上风 |
| 115 | But where does it say that you take somebody just because of that color the place Capitol Street partners back in the summer? | 但是,它说,你带某人 仅仅因为 颜色的地方 Capitol街伙伴 回到夏天? |
| 116 | 2022 said that they will not hire white men for internships | 2022年说他们不会雇用白人来实习 |
| 117 | That's one example of thousands because of how many people are in there how many people know because they wanted to be doesn't again | 这是几千个例子之一 因为里面有多少人 多少人知道,因为他们想成为 不再 |
| 118 | That's irrelevant. | 这无关紧要 |
| 119 | It does not matter if you have an internship and everyone is a white man if they're all qualified | 如果你有实习机会,每个人都是白人,如果他们都是合格的,那也没关系 |
| 120 | That's great. | 赞曰. |
| 121 | They're all Asian or all black. | 它们都是亚洲的或黑色的. |
| 122 | It should be what merit | 这应该是什么优点 |
| 123 | Qualification gets the people into that position and of course, but if it but if this say to school only wanted white people | 资格可以让人们进入这个位置,当然, 但是如果它,但如果说到学校,只想要白人 |
| 124 | No, no good like excellent qualified people and if they end up majority white who cares? | 不,没有像优秀的合格人员一样好 如果他们最终成为白人 谁在乎呢? |
| 125 | Why does that matter? | 这有什么关系? |
| 126 | I don't think that that matters. | 我觉得这不重要 |
| 127 | I'm saying that affirmative action | 我说的是平权行动 |
| 128 | I'm saying that but I'm not saying for the white male or the black race or the Asian race | 我是这么说的 但我不是说白人 黑人或亚洲人 |
| 129 | Or you know understand I'm saying I'm saying that I'm saying that it works in favor for any race and any sex | 或者你知道,我说,我是说,我说,它有利于任何种族和任何性别。 |
| 130 | It works and it does 1000% and I don't just say you're getting that information | 100%有效,我不只是说 你得到的信息 |
| 131 | It is anti white racism that was in the fiber of our laws that is now getting away | 是反白人的种族主义 曾经在我们的法律的纤维 现在正在逃脱。 |
| 132 | Thanks to President Donald Trump where if you were a white man | 多亏了唐纳德·特朗普总统 如果你是白人的话 |
| 133 | especially to apply for internships jobs going to college that it was significantly harder to get those jobs to get into those practices because | 特别是申请进入大学的实习工作,很难得到这些工作来进入这些行业,因为 |
| 134 | There were quotas that made it easier for people other skin colors with lower standards to be able to get those positions | 有了配额,其他肤色标准较低的人更容易获得这些职位。 |
| 135 | We agree. | 我们同意。 |
| 136 | There's only so many slots in a college, right? | 大学里只有这么多空档 对吧? |
| 137 | There's only so many positions in an internship | 实习时只有这么多职位 |
| 138 | There's only it's a it's a limited supply. | 惟有一品有限供养. |
| 139 | I completely agree. | 我完全同意你的观点。 |
| 140 | It is scarcity | 这是稀缺 |
| 141 | So in scarce when you have a scarce resource | 资源紧缺时就很稀少 |
| 142 | You have to decide how you're gonna divvy up that scarce resource for sure in a DEI model. | 你必须决定如何在DEI模型中 将稀缺的资源分出去 |
| 143 | They're gonna say, okay | 他们会说,好吧 |
| 144 | We're not gonna do any more than 30% white and then we'll do 15% until you kind of come up with these quotas | 我们不会做任何超过30%的白人, 然后我们将做15%,直到你 提出这种配额 |
| 145 | Therefore they end up saying well what happens if the 15% black is not qualified | 所以如果15%的黑人没有资格的话,他们最终会说出好话 |
| 146 | they don't care which ends up happening far too often or what happens if the | 他们不在乎最后会发生什么 太频繁了 或者如果发生什么 |
| 147 | You know, give me examples of cases. | 举个例子 |
| 148 | Yeah air traffic control is actually a really good example | 是啊,空中交通管制 其实是一个很好的例子 |
| 149 | We now have all the documents that show that we went on a hiring spree to have more black air traffic controllers | 我们现在有文件显示 我们雇用了更多黑人空中交通管制员 |
| 150 | There's a huge lawsuit about this 15 16 17 | 15 16 17号案有个大案子 |
| 151 | Where the standards for air traffic control dropped so dramatically and you're kind of seeing some of the effects of that potentially | 在空中交通管制标准大幅下降的地方 你可以看到一些潜在影响 |
| 152 | And again, it's in almost every single corporate practice every single college institution | 再说一遍,几乎每个企业都这样 每个学院都这样 |
| 153 | But it just kind of comes down to more of a moral argument that I have which is that if you have something based on merit | 但是,它只是有点降格 到更多的道德争论 我有,这是 如果你有什么 基于功绩 |
| 154 | I want to I don't care if it's all black all Asian all white | 我不管是黑色还是白色 |
| 155 | It's an excellent group is what I want not a diverse group | 这是一个优秀的团体,我想要的不是多样化的团体 |
| 156 | I care about excellence not diversity because I do not believe diversity is a strength. | 我关心卓越而不是多样性,因为我不认为多样性是一种力量。 |
| 157 | I believe unity is a strength | 我相信团结是一种力量 |
| 158 | I believe the pursuit of higher purposes is a strength. | 我认为追求更高的目的是一种力量. |
| 159 | Does that make sense? | 这有道理吗? |
| 160 | Yeah, I do understand where you're coming from | 是的,我明白你来自哪里 |
| 161 | I feel like I do agree with some of the things that you did just say and I may have to do some more research | 我觉得我同意你刚才说的一些话 我可能还要做一些研究 |
| 162 | On the things that you said before but I guess we can agree to disagree for a time being. | 关于你之前说过的话... ...我想我们可以暂时同意不同意 |
| 163 | Thank you for your time | 谢谢你抽空 |
| 164 | I appreciate it. | 谢谢 |
| 165 | Thank you very much just for context | 非常感谢你的上下文 |
| 166 | I'm open to learning and being informed, but I do believe we have a disagreement when it comes to DEI | 我对学习和知情持开放态度 但我相信在DEI问题上我们有分歧 |
| 167 | You think it stands for didn't earn it | 你觉得这代表着没有挣到 |
| 168 | Essentially that colleges are dropping the bar, but I think they're just opening the door | 基本上,大学 放弃吧, 但我认为他们只是打开了门 |
| 169 | So for example | 举个例子 |
| 170 | mmm a | 毫米 a |
| 171 | recent Harvard analysis by topic economics found that students from that wealthiest 1% of families are 13 times more likely to score in the | 最近哈佛大学按主题经济学的分析发现,来自最富有的1%家庭的学生的得分是2004年的13倍。 |
| 172 | 1300 plus range for the SAT SAT than students from the poorest families | 与来自最贫困家庭的学生相比,1300+SAT的学习范围 |
| 173 | And I don't think that's because rich kids are 13 times smarter | 我觉得这不是因为有钱孩子聪明13倍 |
| 174 | But it's because they have access to better schools private tutors test prep everything right | 这是因为他们可以进入更好的学校 私人辅导员测试一切正确的准备 |
| 175 | And according to the University of California, they show that family background | 据加州大学说, 他们显示了家庭背景 |
| 176 | accounts for 40% of the variance in AC SAT slash a CT scores among you see applicants | 占AC SAT中差异的40% 在您中看到的 CT 分数 |
| 177 | I would also like to mention that the | 我还要提及: |
| 178 | Diversing society's leaders the casual effects of emissions at highly selective private colleges a | 使社会领导人多样化,在高度选择性的私立学院中排放的偶然影响a |
| 179 | study shown by the National Bureau of Economic Research that | 国家经济研究局的研究表明: |
| 180 | I think that if you're if you think it's based on race at times. | 我认为如果你认为它有时是基于种族。 |
| 181 | I think it's based on wealth | 我想是建立在财富之上 |
| 182 | So legacy applicants children's of donors and recruited athletes were significantly more likely to be admitted than other students with the same academic credentials | 因此,捐赠者的孩子和被招募的运动员的遗赠申请人被录取的可能性大大高于其他具有同等学历的学生。 |
| 183 | so | 这样 |
| 184 | Yeah, these schools like Harvard legacy students are about five to six times more likely to be admitted than long like list see non | 是啊,这些学校 像哈佛的遗产学生 被录取的几率 大约是长的五到六倍 |
| 185 | Legally non legacy students with similar SAT scores | 具有类似SAT分数的不具有法律意义的学生 |
| 186 | Roughly 43% of white students made it to Harvard from 2002 2015 | 大约43%的白人学生从2002年到2015年进入哈佛大学 |
| 187 | Fell into one of the four categories right legacy athletes Dean's interest lists or children of faculty or staff | 进入四类之一 右传运动员 迪恩的兴趣名单或教职员或职员的子女 |
| 188 | three quarters of these ALDC admins | 四分之三的最不发达国家管理机构 |
| 189 | 75% would not have been admitted if evaluated only on what's the question? | 如果只评估问题是什么,75%不会被录取? |
| 190 | My question is I guess | 我的问题是,我想 |
| 191 | Do you | 你会吗? |
| 192 | Believe that | 相信这一点 |
| 193 | Di | 迪语 |
| 194 | Could possibly not stand for diversity equity and didn't earn it | 可能不能代表多样性的公平 也没有赢得它 |
| 195 | But can stand for actual diversity that diversity of abilities when you go into a job or to school | 但能代表真正的多样性 当你去工作或上学时 能力的多样性 |
| 196 | They don't just ask for your | 他們不只要求你 |
| 197 | SAT score they ask what kind of clubs you were into they ask you to submit an essay they look at they are a holistic | SAT的分数,他们问你是什么样的俱乐部 他们要求你提交一篇论文 他们看它们是一个整体 |
| 198 | academic review so | 学术评论 |
| 199 | Why why do you think it doesn't | 为什么你认为它不 |
| 200 | Didn't it means didn't earn it if maybe they got a less | 难道不是说他们赚不到钱吗? |
| 201 | SAT cool SAT score but them as a person are just more well-rounded than the person who had all these tutors | SAT优异的SAT得分 但他们作为一个人 要比那些导师更完美 |
| 202 | But did nothing outside of it | 但是,除了它之外没有做什么 |
| 203 | What yeah? | 是吗? |
| 204 | Tell me about do you know anything about the students for fair admission case the Supreme Court case at Harvard? | 你对哈佛大学的最高法院 公平录取案了解多少? |
| 205 | I would love to hear yeah, so basically at Harvard Asian and white students | 我很想听,所以基本上 在哈佛亚洲和白人学生 |
| 206 | They basically got two to four hundred points knocked off of their score | 他们基本上得到两到四百分的分数 |
| 207 | Versus black and Hispanic students, so it was disenfranchising white and Asian students | Versus黑人和西班牙裔学生,所以他们剥夺了白人和亚洲裔学生的权利 |
| 208 | So if you support DEI, let's say you're in truck. | 所以,如果你支持DEI, 让我们假设你在卡车。 |
| 209 | You're in charge | 你负责 |
| 210 | Do you think that we should have all test scores be weighed the same? | 你觉得我们所有的测试成绩 都一样吗? |
| 211 | Or do you think that certain ethnic groups should get certain points because of their race I? | 或者你认为某些族群应该因为他们的种族I而获得一定的分数? |
| 212 | believe that we should acknowledge the fact that certain students have a different starting point and I would love to give everybody the | 相信我们应该承认 某些学生有一个不同的起点 我想给每个人 |
| 213 | Opportunity, so how many points should a black student get over a white student in admissions? | 机会,那么黑人学生在招生时应该有多少分? |
| 214 | I think that SAT scores and points shouldn't be the only thing | 我认为SAT的分数和分数 不应该是唯一的事情 |
| 215 | You have to answer the question because the status quo | 你要回答这个问题 因为现状 |
| 216 | It's not that black and white it is so it is because that's that's why affirmative action was struck down | 并不是说黑白一样 因为这就是平权行动被取消的原因 |
| 217 | By the Supreme Court we're not talking about for now action. | 最高法院现在不讨论行动 |
| 218 | We're talking about the DEI | 我们在谈论DEI |
| 219 | Yeah, is an outgrowth for action is an outgrowth of DEI and vice versa, but let me give you another example of DEI | 对,是行动的结果 是DEI的产物,反之亦然,但让我举另一个DEI的例子 |
| 220 | Do you think what if I say to a group? | 你觉得如果我对一个团体说呢? |
| 221 | Let's say of Hispanic and black people if I say you people is that a microaggression | 这么说吧,西班牙人和黑人 如果我说,你们这些人是 一种微观侵略 |
| 222 | Say that again | 再说一遍 |
| 223 | I'm so sorry if I was talking to a group of Hispanic or black people and I happen to say you people is that a | 如果我和一群西班牙人或黑人交谈 我很遗憾 我碰巧说你们是 |
| 224 | Microaggression I would think so. | 微侵略,我想是的。 |
| 225 | Yes. | 对 |
| 226 | Okay. | 摆 |
| 227 | I think that's insane | 我觉得这太疯狂了 |
| 228 | Why because it's not a microaggression or racism to call any group of people you people that's DEI in practice | 为什么因为它不是 微观侵略或种族主义 打电话给任何群体 你的人的 DEI在实践中 |
| 229 | So you guys might know about the group of clowns and the circus group of the Dean on F America thing | 所以你们可能知道 小丑组 和马戏团 院长在F美国的事情 |
| 230 | They fell apart in one week | 他们一周后就散了 |
| 231 | Because one black woman called Dean and Parker racist because they were associated with a woman who called a group of black women | 因为一个叫Dean和Parker的黑人女人是种族主义的 因为他们和一个叫一群黑人女人的女人有关 |
| 232 | You people and they said you did not recognize microaggression | 你们这些家伙,他们说你们认不出小侵略 |
| 233 | That's DEI in practice where you could lose your entire job and your career for one | 这就是DEI的实践,在那里你可以 失去你的全部工作和你的职业生涯之一 |
| 234 | Misstatement and you just you just showed it to me like you think that's a microaggression to say you people to a group of | 说错话了,你只是把它给我看 就像你认为这是微弱的侵略, 说你们是一群人 |
| 235 | Hispanic and black people we should not be policing the speech of people | 西班牙人和黑人 我们不应该监视人们的言论 |
| 236 | Instead we should be carrying out one thing and that's merit and merit only when we put together our institution | 相反,我们应当执行一件事,这才是优点和功绩,只有我们把机构合并起来 |
| 237 | But if you beta sit on meritocracy, like I said, you're initially bringing in wealthy people who have these tutors, but aren't well | 但是如果你像我说的那样坐着做功勋 |
| 238 | That doesn't mean anything. | 这不意味着什么。 |
| 239 | Yes, the degree of how good your parents are matter | 是的,你父母有多好的问题 |
| 240 | Yes, if you have good parents you get something that people with bad parents don't get that's applicable beyond college | 是的,如果你有好父母,你得到的东西 有坏父母的人得不到的东西, 这是适用于大学以后 |
| 241 | But with the people who score higher, let's say they didn't do anything | 但是,对于得分更高的人,让我们假设他们什么也没做 |
| 242 | They are less likely to be able to take on challenges that doesn't matter | 他们不太可能接受无关紧要的挑战 |
| 243 | Why wouldn't it matter? | 为什么这不重要? |
| 244 | Apparently you are penalizing those with good parents the only way you can make this work. | 显然,你惩罚那些有好父母的人 是唯一你能做到这一点的方法。 |
| 245 | You're not penalizing. | 你没在惩罚我 |
| 246 | Yes, you are | 对,你是 |
| 247 | Not true. | 不对 |
| 248 | It is the only way we see this in order to elevate equity | 这是我们提高公平的唯一办法 |
| 249 | You must compromise excellence and that's fine if that's your position because there's only so many spots | 你必须妥协优秀,如果那是你的立场,因为只有这么多的斑点 |
| 250 | There's only so many places and if you have a lot of qualified people and you want to try to get not as qualified people | 只有这么多地方,如果你有很多合格的人... ...而你却想找不合格的人 |
| 251 | You have to prevent the qualified people and elevate the unqualified people | 你必须阻止那些合格的人 提升那些不合格的人 |
| 252 | That's what the students are fair admissions case showed us. | 学生们都是公平的招生案例向我们展示了这一点. |
| 253 | You're thinking that DEI is versus excellence | 你以为DEI是精英 |
| 254 | I think DEI is for excellence. | 我觉得DEI是优秀的。 |
| 255 | Show me one institution that got better the more embraced DEI | 给我看看一个机构,它越好 得到更多的欢迎DEI |
| 256 | What one institution that got better that embraced DEI? | 哪个机构更适合DEI? |
| 257 | That got smarter more competitive leaner more productive and that was better than it was ten years ago | 这比十年前更聪明 更有竞争力 更富有生产力 |
| 258 | Are our airports more efficient? | 我们的机场更有效率吗? |
| 259 | Are we landing planes better? | 我们降落得更好吗? |
| 260 | Are our airlines better? | 我们的航空公司更好吗? |
| 261 | Is our government better? | 我们的政府更好吗? |
| 262 | Is our schools better is our universities better our I mean show me one example as our public health authorities better show me one | 我们的学校好些了吗? 我们的大学好些了? |
| 263 | Institution that's embraced DEI that has become better more excellent than it was 20 years ago | 接受DEI的机构 比20年前更优秀 |
| 264 | It doesn't exist DEI will destroy an institution from within | 它不存在 DEI会从内部摧毁一个机构 |
| 265 | Let me ask you another question when people win kovat happen | 我问你另一个问题 当人们赢得科瓦特的发生 |
| 266 | They remove the SAT scores yet the graduation rates for Harvard were still the same. | 他们取消了SAT的分数 但哈佛的毕业率依然不变 |
| 267 | Do you think that because of sorry | 你觉得是因为对不起 |
| 268 | With that being said since a CT wasn't even considered | 这么说是因为CT还没被考虑 |
| 269 | Schools are accepting people with the potential to succeed because once you get in you're still going off the same | 学校正在接受有成功潜力的人 因为一旦你进入,你还是会失败 |
| 270 | Mare is everybody else a lot of people drop out that are the problem with Harvard | 马雷是其他人 很多人都退学了 哈佛大学的问题 |
| 271 | Is that they now have professors? | 他们现在有教授了吗? |
| 272 | That the ton of them that are saying they have to retake courses and remedial courses because these kids should never be here in | 说他们必须重新上课和修补课程的 因为他们不应该在这里 |
| 273 | The first place and they happen to be a lot of black and Hispanic kids that were let in strictly because of the color of | 首先他们碰巧是很多黑人和西班牙裔孩子 因为肤色而被允许进入 |
| 274 | Their skin. | 他们的皮肤。 |
| 275 | I so I guess my question is do you care about the racial makeup of a college? | 所以我猜我的问题是 你关心大学的种族组成吗? |
| 276 | The racial makeup of a college like if a college was all white or all Asian would that bother you I | 大学的种族组成就像如果一个大学都是白人 或者所有的亚洲人会打扰你 |
| 277 | Think it would stop them from being able to see different perspectives and thus | 觉得这样会阻止他们看到不同的视角,从而 |
| 278 | Improve their systems and improve the quality of their but why is diversity only skin color? | 改善它们的系统,提高它们的质量,但为什么多样性只是肤色? |
| 279 | Can't a bunch of white people also disagree well think of it this way if you if I like like my mom went to the hospital | 如果你喜欢我妈去医院 就不能这样想吗? |
| 280 | or something | 还是什么 |
| 281 | And let's say she her English is good, but her Spanish isn't her Spanish is good, but the English not so much | 她的英语很好 但她的西班牙语不是她的西班牙语 |
| 282 | Right it would help that if a person who is Hispanic or no Spanish would be the one helping her | 没错 如果西班牙人或西班牙人能帮助她 |
| 283 | She'd feel more comfortable with that person because she understands and relates | 她会觉得和那个人比较舒服 因为她理解和联系 |
| 284 | Okay, I mean yeah, you're in America. | 好吧,我的意思是,你在美国。 |
| 285 | You should learn English. | 你应该学英语。 |
| 286 | I don't know what to tell you, but now she is a good | 我不知道该怎么跟你说 但现在她是个好人 |
| 287 | I mean, I'm not trying to be insensitive or cruel, but she would rather be with a Hispanic | 我的意思是,我不是试图不敏感或残忍, 但她宁愿与一个西班牙人 |
| 288 | Nurse versus one that doesn't so she could speak comfortably as an organization you must prioritize something | 护士对一个不让她说得舒服一点的组织 你必须把事情放在优先位置 |
| 289 | We think that excellence should be an we must have an uncompromising | 我们认为优秀应该是一个 我们必须有一个不妥协 |
| 290 | Pursuit and commitment to excellence and not equity and we believe the more that we embrace these mediocre this kind of culture mediocrity | 追求并致力于卓越而不是公平 我们越相信我们接受这种平庸的文化 |
| 291 | excellence will slip and | 优秀会滑倒, |
| 292 | Again, I could go through at the core DEI wants a lot of things including racial quotas | 再说一次,我可以通过核心 DEI想要很多的东西,包括种族配额 |
| 293 | We don't believe in racial quotas our best institutions would fall apart with racial quotas | 我们不相信种族配额 我们最好的机构会随着种族配额崩溃 |
| 294 | We want excellence quotas and the best and the ones that earned it to be able to get in those positions | 我们希望优秀的配额 最好的 和那些赢得它 能够进入这些职位 |
| 295 | Thank you for your good faith conversation. | 谢谢你的真诚谈话 |
| 296 | Mr. | 劳伦斯先生 |
| 297 | Simple. | 简单 |
| 298 | You've said some very nasty things about me online. | 你在网上说了一些关于我的坏话 |
| 299 | So the floor is yours. | 所以,地板是你的。 |
| 300 | Thank you | 谢谢 |
| 301 | Thank you. | 谢谢 |
| 302 | So | 这么说 |
| 303 | simple question simple black theory | 简单的问题 简单的黑理论 |
| 304 | What do you think about blind hiring? | 你觉得盲目的雇佣怎么样? |
| 305 | Are you for blind hiring? | 你是盲目的雇佣吗? |
| 306 | No, no | 没有,没有 |
| 307 | So why not because blind hiring for those you don't know is based on merit where you don't look so | 那为什么不呢 因为盲目为那些你不认识的人 找工作是建立在功绩上呢 |
| 308 | What's blind hiring blind hiring would be that you do not put the race actually when you submit for you know | 盲目雇佣盲目雇佣的 就是你不把比赛 实际当你屈服 |
| 309 | You don't even see the person when you interview them for a job. | 你甚至没有看到那个人 当你采访他们的工作。 |
| 310 | No, no, that's that's one part of blind hiring | 不,不,那是盲目雇佣的一部分 |
| 311 | There's multiple ways to do blind hiring | 有多种方式盲目雇佣 |
| 312 | But at the end of the day blind hire is exactly not knowing the person's race age or gender | 但到头来,盲工根本不知道一个人的种族年龄或性别 |
| 313 | That's based on merit. | 这是基于功绩。 |
| 314 | Like you said you want merit, correct? | 就像你说的 你想要功绩,对不对? |
| 315 | Well, hold on those things can factor into merit as well | 那么,坚持这些东西 也可以考虑优点 |
| 316 | For example, if I'm trying to hire for an Amazon warehouse worker and all of a sudden I find out that they're at 69 with | 例如,如果我想雇一个亚马逊仓库工人 突然发现他们69岁 |
| 317 | One year left from retirement and the age is not disclosed | 离退休还有一年的时间,年龄不予披露 |
| 318 | Wouldn't I prefer to have a 24 year old man than a 69 year old woman who's overweight you're moving the goalpost | 我宁愿有一个24岁的男人 而不是一个69岁的女人 她超重 你移动的门柱 |
| 319 | Let's bring it back here. | 让我们把它带回来这里。 |
| 320 | No, no, no, the whole point was about blind hiring. | 不,不,不,所有的问题 是关于盲目雇佣。 |
| 321 | No, I just said you said race | 不,我只是说你说种族 |
| 322 | Sex and age right is not incorporated. | 性别和年龄权利没有被纳入其中。 |
| 323 | I think you should have a full picture of you | 我想你应该有一个完整的你的照片 |
| 324 | The human being is when you hire them. | 人就是雇他们的时候 |
| 325 | So you care about diversity. | 所以你关心多样性。 |
| 326 | No, actually I don't how why because that's basically merit | 不,实际上我不知道为什么 因为基本上这是优点 |
| 327 | You're focusing solely on merit. | 你只注重功绩 |
| 328 | You said you won't know just be clear | 你说你不会明白的 |
| 329 | I want I if diversity happens naturally through meritocracy great if all of a sudden we have that well, no, no | 如果多样性通过精英管理自然而然地发生的话... ...如果突然间我们有那么好,不,不 |
| 330 | It's not de eyes by force. | 这不是强迫的 |
| 331 | So let me see. | 让我看看 |
| 332 | Yeah. | 对 |
| 333 | No, no. | 没有,没有。 |
| 334 | No, I got it | 不,我来 |
| 335 | I got it interject de eyes that we are going to forcibly make an institution more colorful | 我得到了它插进眼睛,我们要去强迫 使一个机构更多彩 |
| 336 | We're gonna forcibly make an institution more black where if all of a sudden if half of techs | 如果突然有一半的科技人员 |
| 337 | A&M was black because it was all on merit. | A&M是黑色的,因为它都是靠功绩。 |
| 338 | Praise God. | 颂曰. |
| 339 | That's an amazing thing | 真是不可思议 |
| 340 | It doesn't matter if all of a sudden for example | 举个例子,这不重要 |
| 341 | If the NBA is 75% black because it's on merit great terrific | 如果NBA是75%的黑色,因为它的优异 |
| 342 | If the NFL is half black because on merit, we don't want to force race | 如果NFL是半黑色的 因为功绩,我们不想强迫比赛 |
| 343 | We want excellence and meritocracy over race in every possible circumstance | 我们要在一切可能情况下 优异优异的种族 |
| 344 | Right. | 对 |
| 345 | Yeah my turn. | 是的,轮到我了。 |
| 346 | Okay, so | 好吧,这样吧 |
| 347 | Let's get into the NBA for instance, right? | 让我们进入NBA 比如,对不对? |
| 348 | Can we both agree at one point black people weren't allowed into the NBA and then they allow them to be in NBA | 我们能不能同意 黑人不能进入NBA 然后他们允许他们进入NBA |
| 349 | Wouldn't that be considered diversity? | 这不被认为是多样性吗? |
| 350 | Wouldn't that be D? | 那不是D吗? |
| 351 | No, no, no, it's actually the opposite. | 不,不,不,其实恰恰相反。 |
| 352 | You see you're mistaken my friend | 你看,你搞错了我的朋友 |
| 353 | It's actually we're getting rid of any racial stereotyping | 其实我们正摆脱任何种族成见 |
| 354 | What happened was actually a form no DEI is racial stereotyping | 发生的事情其实是一种形式 没有DEI是种族成见 |
| 355 | So what actually was before was a form of white preference DEI, which is white supremacy or whatever | 因此,实际上是什么 白色偏好的形式 DEI,这是白人至上或什么的 |
| 356 | And then we got rid of it | 然后我们摆脱它 |
| 357 | We said we're not gonna discriminate it and the quality of play got better | 我们说过我们不会歧视它 游戏质量会提高 |
| 358 | Do you guys see the difference between the two you see it's very important. | 你们看到两者的区别了吗? 你们认为这很重要 |
| 359 | Well, no, actually I'm talking to both you and the crowd | 不,其实我在跟你和人群说话 |
| 360 | Right. | 对 |
| 361 | I'm talking to both. | 我在跟两个都说话 |
| 362 | Okay, right | 好,对 |
| 363 | so what ended up hat what you want is you actually want to bring back a form of how Major League Baseball and the NBA used to | 所以最后你想要的是什么 你实际上想要带回 一种形式 |
| 364 | Before we desegregated so we can agree that executive order 1 1 2 4 6 is what basically brought in the DEI, correct? | 在取消隔离之前 我们可以同意 行政命令11 2 4 6 基本上是 带进DEI,对不对? |
| 365 | I'm not I think that might be it. | 我觉得不是那样的 |
| 366 | Is that the affirmative action one? | 这是平权行动吗? |
| 367 | I don't know. | 师曰. |
| 368 | No, it's not the format | 不,这不是格式 |
| 369 | 是给DEI的 | |
| 370 | So within that executive order, where does it say that they're solely focused on making people get into jobs? | 因此,在行政命令中,哪里说他们只专注于让人们找到工作? |
| 371 | For instance like United Airlines, right you mentioned that well, let's pause that I'm gonna get to here | 举个例子,联合航空,你说的对,我们暂停一下,我要到这里 |
| 372 | So for an example of DEI is basically your daughter, right? | 所以,一个DEI的例子 基本上是你的女儿,对不对? |
| 373 | She decides to get a job right and unfortunately at that time of the month she goes into the bathroom | 她决定找工作,很不幸在那个月的这个时候,她进了浴室 |
| 374 | Calm down. | 冷静下来。 |
| 375 | She goes into the bathroom | 她去厕所了 |
| 376 | Stop, she's going into the bathroom. | 停下,她要上厕所了 |
| 377 | You're losing the audience. | 你失去了观众。 |
| 378 | I don't care. | 我无所谓 |
| 379 | I'm talking to you | 我在跟你说话呢 |
| 380 | So she she goes into the bathroom, right and she gets it | 所以她去洗手间,对吗? |
| 381 | She goes into the bathroom and gets a tampon or a pad that's been given from the job. | 她去洗手间拿卫生棉条 或从工作得到的垫子 |
| 382 | That is DEI that is literally yes | 这是DEI,字面意思是"是" |
| 383 | Yeah, yeah, yeah, you don't know you don't know you don't know that's great. | 是啊,是啊,是啊,你不知道 你不知道这是伟大的。 |
| 384 | So if you don't know DEI | 所以如果你不认识DEI |
| 385 | Interrupt me so he can win but you don't do that, right or be quiet. | 打断我,让他赢 但你不这样做,对或安静。 |
| 386 | Thank you. | 谢谢 |
| 387 | So right | 这么对 |
| 388 | Can I continue? | 我能继续吗? |
| 389 | Thank you. | 谢谢 |
| 390 | So my thing is dead. | 所以我的东西是死了。 |
| 391 | All right, so | 好吧,这样吧 |
| 392 | Yes, because in it so in executive order 1 1 2 4 6 | 是的,因为行政命令是这样规定的 |
| 393 | They say that DEI is focusing on a safer environment and a more equitable environment within the workplace and the hiring process | 他们说,DEI正在关注一个更安全的环境和一个更公平的环境 在工作场所和雇用过程 |
| 394 | Let's look at Google Google actually does DEI, you know, how they do DEI. | 让我们来看看Google实际上做DEI, 你知道,他们怎么做DEI。 |
| 395 | Give me an example | 举个例子 |
| 396 | Do you know Google's DEI? | 你知道谷歌的DEI吗? |
| 397 | I'm pretty and they shouldn't of course not | 我很漂亮,他们当然不应该 |
| 398 | What is your DEI initiative there was it there there? | 你的DEI倡议是什么? |
| 399 | I actually don't know the specifics because I don't I don't know every company specifics | 其实我不知道具体细节 因为我不知道每个公司的具体情况 |
| 400 | However, let me ask you a question when you're hiring somebody would you rather hire someone that's black or someone that there is excellent? | 然而,让我问你一个问题 当你雇用某人 你宁愿雇用一个黑人 或有一个优秀的人? |
| 401 | So that's what we're talking about. | 故知此义. |
| 402 | That's not what DEI is | 这不是DEI是什么 |
| 403 | Actually, it is so let me let me prove it to you as I said according to the student for fair admission Supreme Court case | 其实,让我来证明给你听 正如我所说,学生们要求最高法院公平录取 |
| 404 | Black students were able to get into Harvard with a switch from it with action | 黑人学生可以进入哈佛大学 有了动作就从中转 |
| 405 | Which is the I affirmative action hold down out your time out shit time out time out. | 那就是我平权行动 拖延你的时间 狗屎时间 关闭时间。 |
| 406 | You're getting too worked up here, man | 你太激动了,伙计 |
| 407 | Okay, time out affirmative action is DEI in practice | 好吧,暂停平权行动 实际是DEI |
| 408 | You see wasn't it I is a very nice right down by Supreme Court. | 你看,这不是我是一个非常好的 在最高法院下方。 |
| 409 | Yes, and they still ignore it | 是的,他们仍然忽略它 |
| 410 | Because they're still ignoring | 因为他们仍然无视 |
| 411 | Let's get back to the core macro tenant | 让我们回到核心的宏观租户 |
| 412 | Which is which I think is very important correct, which is wouldn't you prefer a country built on excellence and merit? | 我认为,这是非常重要的正确, 难道你不喜欢一个建立在优秀和优异基础上的国家吗? |
| 413 | That's what I do based on forced pigmentation diversity. | 这就是我根据强迫色素多样性而做的。 |
| 414 | Why does somebody's skin color matter? | 为什么别人的肤色很重要? |
| 415 | No, tell me what what what differences do you as a black man and me as a white man have and why does it matter? | 不,告诉我,你有什么区别 作为一个黑人,我作为一个白人,有什么区别 和它有什么关系? |
| 416 | Okay, so why does it matter? | 好吧,那有什么关系呢? |
| 417 | So let's look at because again, you don't understand what the eye is and you're trying to put into one stands what which is not | 让我们来看看,因为再次,你不明白什么是眼睛, 你试图把一个站什么不是 |
| 418 | so | 这样 |
| 419 | Thank you. | 谢谢 |
| 420 | So back to this question. | 所以回到这个问题。 |
| 421 | So an executive order and and correct me if I'm wrong | 所以行政命令 如果我错了 纠正我 |
| 422 | You don't know executive order one one two, four six, correct? | 你不知道行政命令 一二四六,对不对? |
| 423 | So I mean I have an idea of what President Trump signed correct | 所以我知道特朗普总统签了什么 |
| 424 | But he got he got rid of that exact right right in that executive order | 但是,他得到了他摆脱 准确的权利 在行政命令 |
| 425 | It says literally yeah, I can Google it too | 上面写着: 是的,我也可以谷歌 |
| 426 | It says that DEI focuses on both the workplace and hiring | 它说,DEI专注于 工作场所和雇佣 |
| 427 | Yes, we should not have any forced diversity period and it's not forced diversity | 是的,我们不应该有 任何强制多样性的时期 也不是强制多样性 |
| 428 | It does not for it say forced diversity and I'll put money on that too. | 它没有说强迫多样性, 我也会为此花钱。 |
| 429 | Does it say diversity? | 是说多样性吗? |
| 430 | It says diversity | 上面写着多样性 |
| 431 | Yeah, well, then it's for it's not forced diversity. | 是啊,那是因为它不是强迫多样性。 |
| 432 | What is it? | 这是什么? |
| 433 | So correct me if I'm wrong, tell me if I'm lying doesn't say forced diversity in executive order | 所以,纠正我 如果我错了, 告诉我,如果我撒谎 不说强制多元化 行政秩序 |
| 434 | Say forced | 说强迫 |
| 435 | Executive order with the word diversity | 具有多样性一词的行政命令 |
| 436 | Better understanding so let's look at Google right Google's one of the hardest companies to actually get into in fact | 更好的理解,让我们看看Google右侧的Google 是实际上最难进入的公司之一 |
| 437 | I believe it's a 0.2 percent chance. | 我相信这是0.2%的机会。 |
| 438 | You actually get the job, right? | 你真的得到了这份工作,对吧? |
| 439 | They actually run a DI initiative their DI initiative is called a hiring committee where they have a diverse group of people | 他们实际上经营一个DI计划 他们的DI计划被称为一个雇佣委员会 他们有不同的人群 |
| 440 | working on me awful how | 对我工作太糟糕了 |
| 441 | So you're telling me Google sucks | 所以你是说谷歌烂透了 |
| 442 | Google actually is honestly so y'all use honestly honestly chat GPT is way better than Google recently. | 谷歌其实是诚实的,所以你们诚实地使用诚实的聊天GPT 比谷歌最近更好。 |
| 443 | I don't know about you guys | 我不知道你们 |
| 444 | No, but honestly to your point though Google has lost its competitive edge in a lot of ways the last ten years | 不,但老实说,你的观点 虽然谷歌在过去十年中 在许多方面失去了竞争优势 |
| 445 | They're a little on a second again Google does a lot, right? | 谷歌的成绩也不错吧? |
| 446 | 但Google已经输掉了社交媒体大战 Google试图推出Facebook竞争对手Instagram竞争对手失败 | |
| 447 | They try to also launch a zoom | 他们也试图发射一个缩放 |
| 448 | Conversation has no Google's market cap Google's market cap otherwise known as alphabet has actually missed | 对话没有谷歌的市场封顶 Google的市场封顶 否则被称为字母实际上错过了 |
| 449 | 与Netflix Amazon、苹果和微软相比, | |
| 450 | In fact, there was a prediction ten years ago that Google would be the first three trillion dollar company | 事实上,十年前有人预测 Google 是第一个三兆美元的公司 |
| 451 | Turns out that it was actually Microsoft that was the first three trillion dollar company | 原来,其实是微软公司 最初的3兆美元公司 |
| 452 | Now, of course alphabet is a very good company on a lot of different ways | 现在,当然字母表 是一个非常好的公司 在很多不同的方式 |
| 453 | But if your argument right now is like well because the one of the biggest companies on the planet has embraced a bad idea | 但是如果你现在的论点还不错的话 因为地球上最大的公司之一 已经接受了一个坏主意 |
| 454 | What is your argument exactly? | 你到底在说什么? |
| 455 | They're still one of the best companies in not because of that because they were built by merit and it's being destroyed by diversity | 他们仍然是最好的公司之一 而不是因为 因为他们是靠功绩建造的 并且被多样性摧毁 |
| 456 | Dei and to get that married and listen if they're hiring people | 迪伊和他结婚 听他们有没有雇人 |
| 457 | Yes | 对 |
| 458 | It makes sense if you're doing a hiring process and you have a hiring committee that is DEI and they're hiring the people | 如果你在做一个雇用过程 你有一个雇用委员会 是DEI,他们正在雇用人 |
| 459 | That's making the company as great as we just said | 这让公司变得跟我们刚才说的一样伟大 |
| 460 | Your argument is that point that takes away Mary it does if we see that Google is doing well and they're using DEI | 你的论点是,如果我们看到Google做得很好, 他们正在使用DEI, Mary就会消失。 |
| 461 | How the hell are you saying that DEI is not making Mary first of all Google has not had this hiring committee around since its inception | 你怎么会说DEI没有让Mary从Google公司成立起 就一直没有这个雇佣委员会呢? |
| 462 | Inception but they had it for a while second people in the committee has been there for a while second is very diverse | 他们有这个想法,但他们有一段时间 第二人已经在那里了一段时间 第二是非常多样化的。 |
| 463 | Secondly, you you have not answered this fundamental question though, which is can you tell me when a | 第二,你还没有回答这个根本问题, 也就是你能告诉我当一个 |
| 464 | Organization gets forcibly more diverse. | 组织被迫变得更加多样化。 |
| 465 | It gets better | 越来越好 |
| 466 | Google again, I just proved to you Google. | 谷歌再次,我刚刚向你证明了谷歌。 |
| 467 | Okay. | 摆 |
| 468 | I just gave you Google again. | 我又给你谷歌了 |
| 469 | 他们用DEI | |
| 470 | Not only are they one of the best companies. | 他们不仅是最好的公司之一。 |
| 471 | Oh, yeah. | 对 |
| 472 | I hate that argument. | 我讨厌这种争论。 |
| 473 | Great. | 不错 |
| 474 | I mean again, it's just they're fine | 再说一遍,他们没事 |
| 475 | I'm not gonna like totally kind of crap on Google, but like more importantly and more more broadly | 我不想在谷歌上胡说八道 但更重要的是 更广泛地说 |
| 476 | I do think you have to answer the question. | 我认为你必须回答这个问题。 |
| 477 | So I can't why does skin color matter at all in hiring answer that question? | 所以,我无法解释为什么 皮肤颜色在雇用中很重要 回答这个问题? |
| 478 | Why is skin color matter? | 为什么肤色很重要? |
| 479 | So if we look at basketball because you love talking about that, right? | 所以,如果我们看篮球 因为你喜欢谈论,对不对? |
| 480 | Can we both agree that at one point there was no black athletes and then what happens? | 我们是否都同意,一度没有黑人运动员,然后会发生什么? |
| 481 | They got rid of forced segregation, which is a form of DEI | 他们摆脱了强制隔离 这是DEI的一种形式 |
| 482 | Diversified the best because it was based on marriage. | 因为它是建立在婚姻基础上的,所以才将最好的人多样化。 |
| 483 | It diversified. | 它多样化。 |
| 484 | Yes, but not | 是的,但是没有 |
| 485 | Very much. | 甚处来. |
| 486 | Hold on. | 坚持住。 |
| 487 | But if your argument is that if you want to make things more merit-based then let's do it | 但如果你的论点是 如果你想让事情更靠功 那就做吧 |
| 488 | It is more merit-based. | 它更注重业绩。 |
| 489 | They made it | 他们成功了 |
| 490 | Diversifying they diverse football basketball bringing black people who are good in it | 让他们多样化的足球篮球 带来那些擅长的黑人 |
| 491 | Nothing is saying I verse nothing. | 我什么都没说,我什么都没说 |
| 492 | You're saying is making any sense | 你说的有道理 |
| 493 | Okay, because what they did of course you don't the NBA went to pure | 好吧,因为他们做了什么 当然你没有NBA去纯洁 |
| 494 | Merit pure excellence. | 完美无缺 |
| 495 | Are you good at this? | 你擅长这个吗? |
| 496 | That's all they cared about in the allowed black people in right exactly because | 这就是他们关心的 在允许的黑人 在正确的原因 |
| 497 | Cuz problem because you know what they had prior was a form of racial | 因为你知道他们以前是什么 种族形式 |
| 498 | Stereotyping and you want more racial stereotyping your worldview is indecipherable from the KKK | 陈规定型和你想更多种族定型 你的世界观是无法从KKK中解析的 |
| 499 | So what you want it's indecipherable because you are race-obsessed. | 所以,你想要的东西是不可破解的 因为你是种族迷。 |
| 500 | I am NOT race-obsessed | 我不是赛车迷 |
| 501 | No, you talk about the race you talk about race more than the Grand Wizard of the KKK | 不,你谈论的种族 你谈论的种族 比大巫师的KKK |
| 502 | Because you the KKK. | 因为你是KKK。 |
| 503 | Well, think about I said your world view think about it | 想想我说过你的世界观会考虑的 |
| 504 | Yeah, because you're around talking about race all the time. | 是的 因为你一直在谈论种族 |
| 505 | I'm talking about character | 我说的是性格 |
| 506 | Which I'll talk about race all the time. | 我会一直谈论种族 |
| 507 | You literally said DEI is based on race when it's not | 你说DEI是基于种族的 |
| 508 | You're getting really upset | 你发脾气了 |
| 509 | For instance, right I've been trying to say this DI one part of DI is literally giving women | 比如说,我一直想说 DI的一部分是给女人 |
| 510 | tampons or pads at work. | 卫生棉条或垫子在工作。 |
| 511 | Oh | 瓳 |
| 512 | Yeah, you're laughing because you know that giving women tampons is a form of DEI. | 是啊,你笑 因为你知道给女人棉条 是DEI的一种形式。 |
| 513 | Yes, it is | 没错 |
| 514 | You know why let me explain. | 你知道为什么让我解释。 |
| 515 | Let me explain | 让我解释一下 |
| 516 | So basically what happens is though the reason why we have DEI is the fact that in a job location, right? | 所以,基本上,会发生什么 是我们有DEI的原因 是在工作地点,对不对? |
| 517 | They want to hire more people of diverse | 他们想雇更多不同种族的人 |
| 518 | So what they is these initiatives these goals these aspirations that they're doing is trying to bring more people in for instance | 因此,这些倡议 这些目标 他们正在做的这些愿望 是试图吸引更多的人 例如, |
| 519 | Like if um, um, what's that store Trader Joe's right? | 就像,如果,嗯,什么是商店 商人乔的权利? |
| 520 | They let people sit down while they let's they ring stuff in they help disability | 他们让人坐下来,而他们让 敲响的东西在他们帮助残疾 |
| 521 | That's DI that helps disabled people get a job at Trader Joe's | 帮助残疾人在Joe商人那里找到工作 |
| 522 | But what you're telling me is that we are not allowed to tell people that for like onboarding onboarding in itself | 但是,你告诉我的是,我们不允许告诉 人们,因为喜欢上船 本身 |
| 523 | It's also DI when they explain to you sexual harassment when they do all these things when they make it more a safer place | 当他们给你解释性骚扰的时候 做这些事情的时候 也会让这里更安全 |
| 524 | That is DI and what you're saying is that the workplace shouldn't be | 这是DI,你的意思是 工作场所不应该是 |
| 525 | I'm safe what you're saying is that more companies | 我安全,你说的 是更多的公司 |
| 526 | Discrimination lawsuit, let's get back. | 歧视诉讼 我们回去吧 |
| 527 | Let's get back | 我们回去吧 |
| 528 | To DEI is racial quotas end of story. | 对DEI来说是种族配额的结局 |
| 529 | Give me one race United Airlines | 给我一个比赛联合航空公司 |
| 530 | Okay, great so so glad go ahead continue what what did United Airlines announce because you know what I said about black pilots | 好吧,太好了,所以很高兴继续什么 联合航空公司宣布,因为你知道我说什么 关于黑人飞行员 |
| 531 | What did they announce when it came to pilots? | 飞行员问起时他们宣布什么? |
| 532 | So why should skin color matter when you board an airplane? | 那么,为什么皮肤的颜色很重要 当你登上飞机? |
| 533 | So just remind everybody is Charlie Kirk's | 所以提醒大家是查理・柯克的 |
| 534 | Idea he basic. | 他的想法是基本的。 |
| 535 | Yes, stop talking. | 是的,停止说话。 |
| 536 | So Charlie Kirk basically | 所以,查理・柯克基本上 |
| 537 | That's very that's very massage. | 这是非常的按摩。 |
| 538 | That's not very DEI of you | 这不怎么适合你 |
| 539 | All right. | 好吧,我们走。 |
| 540 | Let me finish cooking so right | 让我把饭煮好 |
| 541 | So can I can I finish? | 我能说完吗? |
| 542 | So Charlie Kirk said that they're basically hiring women of color to make 40 or 50 percent, right? | 所以查理·柯克说,他们基本上 雇用有色人种的妇女 生产40%或50%,对不对? |
| 543 | But when you actually look into it, what happens is women and people of color, right women and people of color | 但当你真正研究它时, 会发生的是女人和有色人种, 正确的女人和有色人种 |
| 544 | What happens is they're creating a program that's allowing women to train become pilots | 发生的事情是,他们正在创建一个程序 允许妇女训练成为飞行员 |
| 545 | If you actually look at the requirements for these program is nothing different than any other program that trains pilots | 如果你真的看 这些程序的要求 与任何其他培训飞行员的程序没有什么不同 |
| 546 | But you told people that they're just hiring women when that's not true. | 但你告诉人们,他们只是在雇用女人 当这不是真的。 |
| 547 | First of all, I never said that | 首先,我从来没有说过 |
| 548 | Yes, I know what I said secondly when you hire based on race and not on excellence you end up compromising the standards of excellence | 是的,我知道我说的第二,当你雇佣 种族而不是优秀 你最终会损害 优秀的标准 |
| 549 | Allow me to finish without interrupting all right | 让我说完,不要打扰你 |
| 550 | Go ahead when you hire based on race and not on excellence you end up compromising excellence to be able to pursue race | 以种族而不是优异的成绩雇用你 最终会牺牲优秀的成绩 |
| 551 | We know this with Harvard University, California. | 我们和哈佛大学加州分校 |
| 552 | We know this with major companies with the government exactly DEI | 我们知道这一点,大公司与政府 正是DEI |
| 553 | That is a affirmative action is DEI philosophy in | 这是一个平权行动 DEI的哲学 |
| 554 | Allow me to finish my statement | 请允许我结束发言。 |
| 555 | They are actively defined the Supreme Court decision or they are contorting their policies to try to fit their own DEI agenda | 他们正在积极确定最高法院的裁决,或者正在调整其政策,试图适应自己的DEI议程。 |
| 556 | But let me ask you a question if you were to board a United Airlines | 但是,让我问你一个问题,如果你要登上联合航空公司 |
| 557 | If you were to board a flight with United Airlines, would you rather have a pilot that is qualified or one that is diverse? | 如果你要搭乘联合航空的航班,你宁愿有合格的飞行员还是多样化的飞行员? |
| 558 | Answer the question that makes no sense. | 答无明之问. |
| 559 | Why is there two different things? | 为什么有两样东西? |
| 560 | How is it different when you go to American because in the pursuit of diversity in the pursuit of diversity you sacrifice excellence every time | 去美国有什么不同 因为为了追求多样性 你每次都牺牲优秀 |
| 561 | We know this with Harvard. | 我们知道这一点与哈佛。 |
| 562 | We know this with Yale | 耶鲁的事我们都知道 |
| 563 | With the military every time every example that we pursue diversity an institution becomes less excellent | 每当我们追求多样性的每一个例子 都和军队在一起 一个机构变得不那么出色 |
| 564 | So when you when you go on a plane | 当你上飞机时 |
| 565 | Do you go to the pilot and ask for credentials or do you have do you believe that the airline did the right thing? | 你到飞行员那里问证 还是你认为航空公司做了正确的事? |
| 566 | No, so you ask | 不,所以你问 |
| 567 | My statement was when you're going to if you're gonna go from 4% of the pilots being black | 我的声明是当你要去 如果你要去去 从4%的飞行员是黑人 |
| 568 | To 50% of the pilots to be black it begs the question you are going to lower the standards | 对50%的飞行员来说是黑人 这让人觉得问题在于你会降低标准 |
| 569 | So my you are going to what you're gonna put a square peg through a round hole | 所以,我的你要去什么 你要去将一个方 钉通过一个圆洞 |
| 570 | You are going to force something that naturally is not happening and you will all of a sudden be playing a very | 你会强迫一些 自然而然没有发生的事情 你会突然扮演一个非常 |
| 571 | Treacherous and dangerous game when you board a plane when I get heart surgery or if I board a plane | 恐怖而危险的游戏,当你登上飞机 当我得到心脏手术或我登上飞机 |
| 572 | I don't care about the color of the skin of the person doing it. | 不思议行者皮肤之色. |
| 573 | I want excellence and I want meritocracy | 我要优秀的人才,我要优秀的人才 |
| 574 | Yes, yes, so so | 是的,是的,所以这样 |
| 575 | So right let's get back to because you're talking a lot | 好吧,我们回去吧,因为你说话很多 |
| 576 | Final point then I'll get to the next question. | 最后一点,我接着问下一个问题。 |
| 577 | Yeah, that's fair. | 是啊,这是公平的。 |
| 578 | That's fair. | 这很公平。 |
| 579 | Okay | 还好 |
| 580 | So again, so going back to what you said because like I said early ago | 再说一遍,回到你说的话 因为就像我之前说的 |
| 581 | You said I forgot this is you you basically said that um that women are being hired to become pilots, right now first | 你说我忘了这是你 基本上你说,嗯... 女人被雇用成为飞行员, 现在第一 |
| 582 | That's not a that's a lie. | 这不是一个谎言。 |
| 583 | That's based on a program second. | 这是基于程序第二。 |
| 584 | What? | 你说什么? |
| 585 | Correct me if I'm wrong becoming a pilot. | 如果我做错了飞行员,就纠正我 |
| 586 | It's based on skill, correct? | 这是基于技能,对不对? |
| 587 | It's not based on high | 这不是基于高 |
| 588 | It's not based on on on physicality doesn't based on not this based on skill meaning | 不是以体力为本 不是以技能为本 |
| 589 | No, if you're being oh, so what is it based on because based on a now public lawsuit with the Department of Transportation in 2016 2017 | 不,如果你是Oh,那它有什么依据 因为基于现在的公开诉讼 在交通部 在2016 2017年 |
| 590 | Air traffic controllers and pilot standards were lowered in pursuit of natural look at that too because of over 15 more | 空中交通管制员和飞行员标准也因超过15人而降低,以追求自然的眼光 |
| 591 | Let me finish because of 15 whistleblowers that said the standard of air traffic controllers and pilots were being sacrificed in the pursuit of diversity | 让我说完,因为有15个吹哨人 说空中交通管制员和飞行员的标准 为了追求多样性而牺牲了 |
| 592 | I'm lying again inclusion. | 我又在撒谎了 |
| 593 | You're lying again. | 你又在撒谎了 |
| 594 | Okay. | 摆 |
| 595 | I mean people can do their own independent research and I've done it | 我的意思是,人们可以做自己的独立研究 我已经做了 |
| 596 | They actually made it harder they add more scenarios within the FAA everybody here | 他们实际上更难,他们增加了更多的情景 在FAA每个人在这里 |
| 597 | Yeah, okay. | 是啊,没关系。 |
| 598 | Again the the documents bear out exactly we now have | 这些文件再次证明了我们现在所掌握 |
| 599 | We have air traffic controllers after air traffic controllers have said in the pursuit of making air traffic controlling more diverse | 在空中交通管制员说到之后,我们有空中交通管制员 试图使空中交通管制更加多样化 |
| 600 | We have then lowered the quality of air traffic control | 然后我们降低了空中交通管制的质量 |
| 601 | so at the end of all this what you basically told me is that if | 所以在这一切的结尾 你基本上告诉我,如果 |
| 602 | Matters you don't it doesn't matter because when we mentioned blind hiring you said you're against that which is based on merit | 事情你并不重要,因为当我们提到盲目雇佣时 你说你反对以功为本 |
| 603 | No timeout. | 没有超时。 |
| 604 | They said that they want to prioritize a group above. | 他们说,他们想优先对待以上群体。 |
| 605 | What is merit meritocratic? | 功绩如何? |
| 606 | I didn't say that that that's what United Airlines said they said | 我没说那是联合航空公司说的 |
| 607 | Again they said half of all their new hires you got cooked again | 他们又说一半的新工你又煮了 |
| 608 | We we have clarity and the clarity is very simple | 我们很清楚,很简单 |
| 609 | We want a country based on content and merit. | 我们希望有一个基于内容和功绩的国家。 |
| 610 | He wants a retribal ization of America | 他想让美国回归部落化 |
| 611 | Thank you | 谢谢 |
该视频共有字幕 615 条。解锁更多字幕为会员功能，请移动到 价格